US ELECTION

The United States is ready to choose its next President in the 2024 general election, with Electoral College voting scheduled for today, November 5, 2024.

Electoral College System in the US

Purpose and Function

  • The Electoral College formally elects the U.S. president and vice president.
  • Instead of direct votes for the president, citizens vote for electors aligned with each candidate’s party.

Process

  • Each state’s electors, chosen by popular vote, cast the final votes for president and vice president.
  • A total of 538 electors make up the Electoral College, with 270 votes required to win.

Historical Background

  • Established in the U.S. Constitution as a middle ground between direct voting and congressional appointment.
  • Designed to balance popular input with a layer of oversight on executive selection.

Impact

  • Allows for cases where the national popular vote winner loses the presidency if they do not win the Electoral College.
  • Notably occurred in the 2000 and 2016 elections.

How the Indian Presidential Election Differs from the U.S. Presidential Election

  • Electoral College Composition: The Indian President is elected by an electoral college that includes:
    • Elected Members of Parliament (MPs): Both Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha elected members.
    • Elected Members of Legislative Assemblies (MLAs): From all states and the Union Territories of Delhi and Puducherry.
  • Nomination Process: A candidate must submit a nomination with support from 50 proposers and 50 seconders, who must be part of the electoral college.
  • Voting Process: Electoral college voters rank candidates by preference on the ballot, rather than voting directly for a party candidate.
  • Vote Value Calculation: Vote values differ:
    • MPs: Each MP has a vote value of 700.
    • MLAs: Each MLA’s vote value is based on the population-to-MLA ratio of their state, divided by 1,000 (e.g., UP MLA votes are valued at 208, while Arunachal Pradesh MLA votes are valued at 8).
  • Winning Requirement: The candidate must secure 50% + 1 of total votes, unlike U.S. elections, which require only a simple majority.

Similarities between Indian and U.S. Presidents

  • Head of State: Both serve as ceremonial heads of state, representing their nations at official and diplomatic events.
  • Election Process: Both are elected for their roles, though India uses an indirect system, while the U.S. uses a direct election.
  • Veto Power: Both hold veto authority over legislation passed by their legislatures.
  • Emergency Powers: Each can declare a state of emergency and assume special powers, though the specifics vary.
  • Diplomatic Role: Both negotiate treaties and manage international relations.
  • Ceremonial Duties: Both perform ceremonial tasks, including law inaugurations, granting honors, and hosting foreign dignitaries.

Differences between Indian and U.S. Presidents

Aspect Indian President U.S. President
Powers Primarily ceremonial with limited executive authority, real power lies with the Prime Minister. Significant executive authority, serving as both head of state and government.
Functioning Acts on the advice of the Council of Ministers, with decisions made collectively. Has autonomy in executive decisions, appointing officials, and issuing executive orders.
Election Process Elected by an Electoral College of Parliament and State Legislative Assembly members. Elected directly by citizens who vote for electors, who then vote for the president.
Term Duration Five-year term, eligible for unlimited reelections. Four-year term, with a maximum of two terms (eight years total).
Impeachment Impeachment for violating the Constitution requires a two-thirds majority in both parliamentary houses. Impeached for treason, bribery, or high crimes; initiated by the House and tried by the Senate.
Executive Authority Acts mainly on the Prime Minister’s advice with limited independent authority. Has independent authority to appoint federal officials and direct the executive branch.
Privileges Enjoys immunity for actions in official capacity. Holds broader privileges, including executive privilege to withhold information from Congress and courts.
Immunity Immune from legal proceedings for official actions but can be sued for personal actions. Immune from civil suits for official actions but can face criminal charges for illegal activities.
Political Affiliation Typically affiliated with a political party but expected to act impartially in office. Elected on party lines and engages in partisan politics, representing a political party.

Leave a Reply